Thursday, February 25, 2016

Anecdotal Fallacy

The anecdotal fallacy is using personal experience instead of a actual fact and content validate an argument. An example of this would be saying that eating a lot of candy won't give you a cavity because John's cousin eats a pound of candy a week regularly, and his teeth are perfectly fine. This gives the idea that just because John's cousin can do that that you can eat a bunch of candy and you won't get a cavity. But what this fallacy fails to realize that everyone is different and that ones persons experience will not be the same as another's.

Another example would an argument that cigarettes don't kill because James smoked a pack of cigarettes a day his whole life and he lived to be 100 then died of old age. The flaw with this is that although James smoked a pack of cigarettes a day and lived to be a 100 without dying from cigarettes, there are statistics that prove that thousands of people have died due to their addiction to cigarettes. This fallacy is used in daily in all types of persuasion, including peer pressure. People fall victim this fallacy because they hear that someone they know went through something risky and came out with no repercussions, so they believe they can do it too regardless of the many facts against it.

This fallacy can be dangerous because it can be misleading. Everybody is different so you shouldn't get caught up in someone else's experience. Rather than one mans experience you should sticking to what the facts say.

smoking cigarette stress stressed busy

"Cigarettes are gonna be the death of you" 

3 comments:

  1. Another one I used to hear on college related to the anecdotal fallacy had to do with drinking/alcohol consumption: "I can do the 'all-you-can-eat' buffet at Red Lobster and not gain a pound. You'll be fine, too. Just have one more round." Ah, youth!
    Nice examples here!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I enjoyed reading your post. I think this is a good example of the Anecdotal Fallacy. Your graphic included is funny to me and I think it fits well with your post. Also, I'm glad you wrote about how this can be misleading due to everyone having their own experiences and how not everyones experience may be the same. Overall good job on this post.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Great post Lloyd. Your examples were perfect for anecdotal fallacy. I personally don't like cigarettes and the affect that its had on our world. So the comment about smoking and how David smoked a pack a day and lived to 100, really caught my attention. Just because one person experienced that, doesn't mean its going to work for everyone. It's quite ridiculous how people will actually believe that. But I mean whatever floats their boats. Your comment about eating was very interesting as well.

    ReplyDelete